Rattle & Hum

[BlueBlue]

I need some help with Rattle & Hum. U2Songs lists the tracklist of the CD and a lot of additional information which is great. However, even though there is an entry for the DVD / BluRay it doesn't reflect the differences between both. Can anybody tell me / guide me to a resource which has a detailed tracklisting for the DVD / BluRay which includes what track is live / studio and where it was recorded in case it is live.

Thank you in advance.

[Aaron]

Try the Rattle and Hum movie link again here:

http://www.u2songs.com/discography/u2_rattle_and_hum_movie

It does need some clean up which is why you couldn't see the tracks before.  But it should give you an idea of what is there. I'll try to clean it up a bit more tomorrow.

[BlueBlue]

Thanks Aaron. From what I can see two issues:

1) Track Splitting

I have a bluray rip with 20 tracks, U2songs lists 21 tracks. Difference: Freedom For My People / Silver and Gold is one track in my rip.

2) Runtimes

In my bluray rip runtimes vary significantly from those listed on U2songs. Example: Sunday Bloody Sunday runs in my bluray rip 07:49 (incl. approx. 20 sec interview segment) whereas U2songs says 06:01

Would by great if you could verify the U2songs entries.

[Aaron]

Thanks Aaron. From what I can see two issues:

1) Track Splitting

I have a bluray rip with 20 tracks, U2songs lists 21 tracks. Difference: Freedom For My People / Silver and Gold is one track in my rip.

2) Runtimes

In my bluray rip runtimes vary significantly from those listed on U2songs. Example: Sunday Bloody Sunday runs in my bluray rip 07:49 (incl. approx. 20 sec interview segment) whereas U2songs says 06:01

Would by great if you could verify the U2songs entries.

The information that is there is taken from the VHS tape and dates back to '98 - '00 when we first did the entries.  So no surprise there would be differences.

[BlueBlue]

I see. Thank you AAAron.

[enaul]

This is my personal split of the DVD.
Hope This Helps.

Code: [Select]

REM GENRE Rock
REM DATE 1998
TITLE "1988-10-04 Rattle And Hum The Movie"
FILE "U2 - 1988-10-10 Rattle And Hum The Movie.flac" WAVE
  TRACK 01 AUDIO
    TITLE "'This Is A Song Charles Manson Stole From The Beatles' (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Bono"
    INDEX 01 00:00:00
  TRACK 02 AUDIO
    TITLE "Helter Skelter (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 00:16:49
  TRACK 03 AUDIO
    TITLE "Van Diemen's Land (Studio Version)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 03:03:16
  TRACK 04 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Is Film Expensive'"
    PERFORMER "U2, Phil Joanou"
    INDEX 01 05:10:30
  TRACK 05 AUDIO
    TITLE "Desire (Live Dublin, Ireland, Point Depot)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 05:57:45
  TRACK 06 AUDIO
    TITLE "'What's This Film About'"
    PERFORMER "U2, Phil Joanou"
    INDEX 01 08:37:70
  TRACK 07 AUDIO
    TITLE "Exit - Gloria (snippet) (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 09:48:50
  TRACK 08 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 13:54:38
  TRACK 09 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Well We Wrote This Song I Still Haven't Found'"
    PERFORMER "Edge"
    INDEX 01 14:02:20
  TRACK 10 AUDIO
    TITLE "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For (Live 1987-09-28 New York City, NY, Madison Square Garden)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 15:01:47
  TRACK 11 AUDIO
    TITLE "Freedom For My People (Live 1987)"
    PERFORMER "Sterling Magee, Adam Gussow"
    INDEX 01 18:29:50
  TRACK 12 AUDIO
    TITLE "Silver And Gold (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 19:18:38
  TRACK 13 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 24:54:35
  TRACK 14 AUDIO
    TITLE "Press Conference"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 24:58:63
  TRACK 15 AUDIO
    TITLE "Angel Of Harlem (1987-11-28 ?? Memphis, TN, Sun Studio)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 25:36:07
  TRACK 16 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Music Can Get So Boring'"
    PERFORMER "Edge"
    INDEX 01 28:17:03
  TRACK 17 AUDIO
    TITLE "All Along The Watchtower (Live 1987-11-11 San Francisco, CA, Justin Herman Plaza)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 28:30:30
  TRACK 18 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 33:06:72
  TRACK 19 AUDIO
    TITLE "In God's Country (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 33:10:38
  TRACK 20 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Thank You' (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Bono"
    INDEX 01 34:58:17
  TRACK 21 AUDIO
    TITLE "Backstage (Live 1987-11-24 Fort Worth, TX, Tarrant County Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 35:51:19
  TRACK 22 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Let Me introduce To You' (Live 1987-11-24 Fort Worth, TX, Tarrant County Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Bono"
    INDEX 01 36:39:52
  TRACK 23 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-24 Fort Worth, TX, Tarrant County Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 36:55:46
  TRACK 24 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Believe It Or Not' (Live 1987-11-24 Fort Worth, TX, Tarrant County Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Bono"
    INDEX 01 37:11:28
  TRACK 25 AUDIO
    TITLE "Backstage (Live 1987-11-24 Fort Worth, TX, Tarrant County Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2, B.B. King"
    INDEX 01 37:22:20
  TRACK 26 AUDIO
    TITLE "When Love Comes To Town (Live 1987-11-24 Fort Worth, TX, Tarrant County Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2, B.B. King"
    INDEX 01 38:12:34
  TRACK 27 AUDIO
    TITLE "'A Lot Of Emotion' (Live 1987-11-24 Fort Worth, TX, Tarrant County Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2, B.B. King"
    INDEX 01 41:11:12
  TRACK 28 AUDIO
    TITLE "Heartland (Studio Version)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 41:22:70
  TRACK 29 AUDIO
    TITLE " "
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 45:19:73
  TRACK 30 AUDIO
    TITLE "Bad - Ruby Tuesday (snippet) - Sympathy For The Devil (snippet) (Live 1987-11-08 denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 45:24:52
  TRACK 31 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 53:09:52
  TRACK 32 AUDIO
    TITLE "Where The Streets Have No Name (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 53:19:51
  TRACK 33 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Thank You' (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "Bono"
    INDEX 01 59:19:41
  TRACK 34 AUDIO
    TITLE "Mlk (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 59:29:15
  TRACK 35 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 61:18:62
  TRACK 36 AUDIO
    TITLE "With Or Without You (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 61:27:65
  TRACK 37 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Mix Music With Politics'"
    PERFORMER "Adam Clayton"
    INDEX 01 66:38:03
  TRACK 38 AUDIO
    TITLE "The Star Spangled Banner (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "Jimi Hendrix"
    INDEX 01 66:50:29
  TRACK 39 AUDIO
    TITLE "Bullet The Blue Sky (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 67:05:15
  TRACK 40 AUDIO
    TITLE "Running To Stand Still (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 72:13:56
  TRACK 41 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-12-20 Tempe, AZ, ASU Sun Devil Stadium)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 76:19:70
  TRACK 42 AUDIO
    TITLE "'That Day'"
    PERFORMER "Bono"
    INDEX 01 76:25:54
  TRACK 43 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 76:44:14
  TRACK 44 AUDIO
    TITLE "'Well Here We Are The Irish In America' (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Bono"
    INDEX 01 76:49:28
  TRACK 45 AUDIO
    TITLE "Sunday Bloody Sunday (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 77:46:10
  TRACK 46 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 83:49:69
  TRACK 47 AUDIO
    TITLE "Pride (In The Name Of Love) (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 83:57:16
  TRACK 48 AUDIO
    TITLE "Audience (Live 1987-11-08 Denver, CO, McNichols Sports Arena)"
    PERFORMER "Audience"
    INDEX 01 88:04:60
  TRACK 49 AUDIO
    TITLE "All I Want Is You (Studio Version)"
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 88:29:66
  TRACK 50 AUDIO
    TITLE " "
    PERFORMER "U2"
    INDEX 01 94:41:21


[BlueBlue]

Thans for sharing Enaul. Just to be clear: the cue sheet you shared is one you made on your own and does not necessarily correspond to the chapter marks of the DVD / BluRay does it?

[enaul]

Just to be clear: the cue sheet you shared is one you made on your own and does not necessarily correspond to the chapter marks of the DVD / BluRay does it?

Correct. A few years ago i ripped all the sound of my U2 DVDs of the complete chapter (created VOB in DVD Decrypter, extracted audio in eac3to). These cue sheets (created with CD Wave and tweaked with Notepad++ and with foobar2000) were a reflection of the way i liked to hear the tracks seperately.
For this one, i have some favourites, a.o. Desire, Exit, Sunday Bloody Sunday.

[BlueBlue]

Thanks Enaul. Something I'm particularly interested in is the date and location of the live tracks. Unfortunately, my BluRay doesn't contain any information about it, however, you have them in your cue sheet. Where did you get those from?